November 22, 2026

Your College Football Program Might Not Have a Plan. Just a Budget.

The sport keeps buying talent and calling it progress. Those are not the same thing. There is a receipt for almost everything in college football now. The coach. The coordinators. The quarterback. The next quarterback, if the first one does not work out. What remains harder to purchase is an answer to a fairly basic question.

Your College Football Program Might Not Have a Plan. Just a Budget.

What, exactly, are you building? Not what are you spending. Not whom did you beat for a commitment. Not how many people celebrated the announcement. What kind of football team are all these decisions supposed to produce? The question can sound almost quaint in a sport so occupied with the next acquisition. It is also the question that separates investment from expensive wandering.

Saturday provided several useful illustrations. Navy beat Memphis with a late drive it finished on fourth down. Nebraska beat Ohio State by keeping its offense on the field when one more Buckeyes possession might have changed everything. Michigan handed UCLA its first loss in a game nobody would confuse with an offensive exhibition.

Three different winners. Three different circumstances. No universal blueprint. That should be a feature of college football, not a problem programs keep spending money to eliminate.

Fit Is What Happens After the Announcement

Nebraska’s Anthony Colandrea accounted for all four Cornhuskers touchdowns in a 31–28 victory over Ohio State. The telling part came after the scoring. Nebraska needed to keep the ball. Colandrea’s running helped produce the first downs that allowed the Cornhuskers to finish without asking their defense to survive another possession.

That is a useful place to begin evaluating a quarterback. Not with his position in an offseason hierarchy. With the problem he helped his team solve. Recruiting reputation matters because talent matters. But reputation is an introduction, not an operating manual. A staff still has to identify what a player does well, determine how those strengths interact with the rest of the roster, and create enough answers for the moments when the preferred play is unavailable.

Credits – Madison Penke

A player can be talented and wrong for the assignment. A system can be sound and wrong for the personnel. When that happens, somebody has to change something besides the recruiting pitch. Too often, the proposed correction is another acquisition. Sometimes that is necessary. Sometimes it allows the adults making the decisions to postpone examining their own.

Different Does Not Mean Unsophisticated

Navy’s winning touchdown against Memphis came on a six-yard run, on fourth down, with 15 seconds remaining. The stakes were obvious. So was the importance of the next snap. Navy executed anyway. That does not mean other programs should install Navy’s offense. It means an approach deserves to be judged by the advantages it creates, not its resemblance to whatever happens to look most fashionable on television.

The same caution applies in reverse. An unconventional offense is not automatically brilliant. A traditional approach is not inherently dependable. Neither deserves protection from evidence. Michigan’s 18–16, triple-overtime victory over UCLA was consequential without being beautiful.

Coaches are employed to find a viable way through the game in front of them. Sometimes that requires attacking space. Sometimes it requires controlling it. Sometimes the offense must carry the afternoon. Sometimes it must stop putting the defense in impossible positions. The sophistication is in recognizing the assignment and having answers. The presentation is secondary.

Money Matters. So Does Knowing What It Is For.

There is a sentimental version of this argument that should be rejected immediately. It suggests a clear identity and a clever coach can make resource disparities disappear. They cannot. Better players change games. Depth changes seasons. A program with more resources can often survive an injury, an evaluation mistake, or a disappointing acquisition more easily than one operating with less room for error.

Money buys possibilities. But the existence of those possibilities does not guarantee anybody has arranged them intelligently. A school can assemble a talented roster and still ask its offensive line to execute poorly matched concepts. It can acquire a celebrated quarterback without providing a credible way to protect him. It can collect defensive athletes without establishing a defense they execute together.

Those are not arguments against spending. They are arguments for knowing what the spending is meant to accomplish. Before committing resources to the next player, a program should understand whether it is addressing a personnel shortage, a development failure, or a problem of its own design. The wrong diagnosis can make the next transaction look remarkably like the last one.

An Identity Is Not an Alibi

Of course, “we know who we are” has excused plenty of stubborn football. A coach can become so committed to an approach that every unsuccessful Saturday is blamed on the players’ inability to execute it. The system remains above examination. The roster is always one recruiting class away.

That is not coherence. It is insulation. A run-oriented team needs answers when it falls behind. A passing offense needs alternatives when protection breaks down. A program built around defense cannot indefinitely describe offensive failure as the price of its philosophy. A useful identity clarifies decisions. It does not end the discussion.

The best question is not whether a staff believes in its plan. Presumably it does. The question is what evidence would persuade it to adjust. That applies to administrators, too. They should be able to explain how the coach, the roster, the development structure and the financial commitments support one another. If those answers point in different directions, the problem is not necessarily a shortage of ambition.

It may be an absence of agreement about what ambition requires. College football does not need every program to become a version of its richest contender. Nor does it need romantic defenses of every team doing something different. It needs a more demanding way to distinguish a plan from a collection of purchases.

What advantage are you trying to create? Have you acquired the players to create it? Can your coaches teach it? Can they adapt when it stops working? Those questions will not win many announcement days. They might prevent a school from paying for another one it did not need.

Further reading

Twitter feed is not available at the moment.

Subscribe to Podcast